The resulting dfs tree d is represented by an array parent. However, i am still unable to use the answer in order to display the result correctly. Each execution of the general step requires o rn time, and the algorithm performs n 1 executions of. Implements a nearlinear time iterative dominator generator based on the paper a simple, fast dominance algorithm using an iterative method 1. Lengauer and tarjan developed an algorithm which is almost linear, and in practice, except for a few artificial graphs, the algorithm and a simplified version of it are as fast or faster than any other known algorithm for graphs of all sizes and its advantage increases with graph size. In this article i am going to explain the concept of dominators in a directed graph, its applications and an efficient algorithm for construction of dominator tree published by robert tarjan 1. The dominance problem is an excellent example of the need to balance theory with practice. We can also answer dominance queries test if a vertex u. Because the immediate dominator is unique, it is a tree. A fast algorithm for finding dominators in a flowgraph is presented. Successive improvements of this algorithm were done by aho and ullman 14, purdom and moore 15, and tarjan 16, culminating in lengauer and tarjans 1 oe. Bysolvingthelocal problem for the microtrees,they can performthe subsequentunion. A fast algorithm for finding dominators in a flowgraph. The lengauer tarjan algorithm is a fast algorithm for general flowgraphs.
A new, simpler lineartime dominators algorithm adam l. The lengauer tarjan algorithm for computing the immediate dominator tree of a flowgraph by. An algorithm due to lengauer and tarjan runs in time oe. Their algorithm is essentially a divideandconquer algorithm that groups the bottom nodes of the depth. In this work, we aim at integrating such techniques in. The lengauer tarjan algorithm for computing the immediate. In contrast, production compilers, like gcc or llvm, implement the classic, efficient lengauertarjan algorithm, to compute dominator trees. In my analysis, i found that for both random and compiler generated graphs, lengauer tarjan still proved fastest for large graphs. An easy way to build dominator tree is to use iterative bit vector algorithm, but it may be slow in the worst case. In bug 666426, dominators were introduced to ionmonkey to help with various optimization stuff i assume ssa related, but i digress.
Im using the lengauer and tarjan algorithm with path compression to calculate the dominator tree for a graph where there are millions of nodes. Tarjans strongly connected components algorithm wikipedia. Appel 1998 provides a thorough description of the lt algorithm. In this post, tarjans algorithm is discussed that requires only one dfs traversal. Since there is a lot of content to be covered, the post is going to be a bit long. View notes a fast algorithm for finding dominators in a flow graph from soen 6431 at concordia university. Strongly connected components kosarajus algorithm graph algorithm duration. A strongly connected component is a maximum set of vertices, in which exists at least one oriented path between every two vertices. Tarjans algorithm is a procedure for finding strongly connected components of a directed graph. Thus, their algorithm has better asymptotic complexity than lengauer tarjan. A dominator tree is a tree where each nodes children are those nodes it immediately dominates. Each execution of the general step requires o rn time, and the algorithm performs n 1 executions of the general step.
Lengauertarjan algorithm iterative setbased algorithm for finding dominator trees is slow in worst case lengauertarjan is near linear time uses depthfirst spanning tree from start node of control flow graph see books for details uw csf p. An efficient algorithm for finding doublevertex dominators. A similar example, but for a family of directed acyclic. Lengauer and tarjan 30 proposed two versions of a fast algorithm for. Integer is if haschildren node then result pdf file. Lca basics, disjoint set union by rank and path compression we are given a treecan be extended to a dag and we have many queries of form lcau, v, i.
And subsequent optimization phases can then determine whether a cfg node dominates another node in constant time by using their respective depthfirst search numbers in the dominator tree. A postdominator tree is analogous to the dominator tree. They concluded that both versions of their algorithm were much faster than the. Lengauer tarjan algorithm in bgl boost graph library. However, in the experiment, purdommoore lost ground, moving the crossover point by lengauer tarjan to seven nodes. Algorithms for finding dominators in directed graphs.
Improving on previous work by tarjan 41, lengauer and tarjan 30 proposed an om log ntime algorithm and a more complicated om. We are currently investigating if such an ordering can be found e. There is an arc from block m to block n if m is an immediate dominator of n. The lengauertarjan algorithm here we outline the lengauer and tarjan lt approach lengauer and tarjan 1979 at a high level, to provide some details needed by our algorithm. For example, consider vertex g in dfs tree d in figure 1a. Organization dominator relation of cfgs postdominator relation dominator tree computing dominator relation and tree dataflow algorithm lengauer and tarjan algorithm controldependence relation ssa form controlflow graphs cfg is a dag unique node start from which all nodes in cfg are reachable. The previously discussed algorithm requires two dfs traversals of a graph. Lengauer and tarjan developed an algorithm which is almost linear, but its implementation tends to be complex and time consuming for a graph of several hundred nodes or fewer. However, they state that their algorithm runs ten to twenty percent slower than lengauer tarjan on \real owgraphs 11. They concluded that both versions of their algorithm were much faster even on graphs of moderate size. Lengauer and tarjan 17 proposed two versions of a fast algorithm for finding dominators and compared them experimentally with an iterative bit vector algorithm. We also found the bit vector algorithm does compete with lengauer tarjan for small graphs. The dominator tree can be calculated efficiently using lengauertarjans algorithm.
Dominator tree of a directed graph algorithm tutorials. They chose to go with the simple iterative approach instead of using the pdf linked in comment 0 because it is actually faster in many cases than the lengauertarjan algorithm and is easier to implement. Random graph cintcode instruction counts nodes edges seed v. Their algorithm is also the most widely used in the compiler community, although there are asymptotically faster algorithms available that run in linear time harel 1985. The lengauer tarjan algorithm for computing the immediate dominator tree of a flowgraph by martin richards. In my analysis, i found that for both random and compiler generated graphs, lengauertarjan still proved fastest for large graphs. We let g0and d0denote the ow graph and its dominator tree after the update.
A fast algorithm for finding dominators in a fiowgraph thomas lengauer and robert endre. I, called the dominator tree of g, in which the dominators of a vertex v are its ancestors. But if a graph is acyclic, do we have a faster alg. Computing a dominator graph using boosts lengauer tarjan. Tarjans algorithm is an algorithm in graph theory for finding the strongly connected components of a directed graph. In conference record of the 21st acm symposium on principles of programming languages. A fast algorithm for finding dominators in a flowgraph acm. Aug 27, 2019 floyds algorithm implemented in pgrouting can also answer reachability question. Bysolvingthelocalproblem for the microtrees, theycanperform the subsequent. Every node z visited before xs parent is control dependent on x.
Lengauertarjan algorithm and the hybrid algorithm were most consistently fast, and their ad. Lengauer and tarjan developed an algorithm which is almost linear, and in practice, except for a few artificial graphs. Also lengauer tarjan dominator tree is not implemented before in pgrouting. However, in the experiment, purdommoore lost ground, moving the crossover point by lengauertarjan to seven nodes. Now consider the e ect that a single edge update insertion or deletion has on the dominator tree d. Integer is if haschildren node then result algorithm for maintaining the dominator tree of a reducible flowgraph. Let me first of all apologize in case i have violated the rules, as i am aware my question has already been asked in a modified way here. Tarjans algorithm is named for its inventor, robert tarjan. Pdf the computation of dominators in a flowgraph has applica tions in. A fast algorithm for finding dominators in a flowchart cs.
Tarjans offline lowest common ancestors algorithm prerequisite. A simple implementation of the algorithm runs in o m log n time, where m is the number of edges and n is the number of vertices in the problem graph. This graph is a tree, since each block has a unique immediate dominator. The lengauer tarjan algorithm is better understood, however, and has a clear implementation.
It is known 19 that the dominator tree i is such that if w is a vertex in. As an interesting aside, their analysis suggests that, for many classes of graphs. A new, simpler lineartime dominators algorithm request pdf. An easy way to build dominator tree is to use iterative bit vector algorithm, but it may. We address the following important instance of this problem.
A fast algorithm for finding dominators in a flowgraph 123 to analyze the running time of this algorithm, let us assume that g has m edges and n vertices. We have discussed kosarajus algorithm for strongly connected components. We also found the bit vector algorithm does compete with lengauertarjan for small graphs. Jan 11, 2016 dominator tree of a directed graph link to pdf version.
Is there a fast algorithm to compute dominator tree for acyclic graphs. Lengauertarjan algorithm and the hybrid algorithm were most. Efficient way to recursively calculate dominator tree. Validating dominator trees for a fast, verified dominance test. Dominator relation of cfgs postdominator relation dominator tree computing dominator relation and tree dataflow algorithm lengauer and tarjan algorithm controldependence relation ssa form controlflow graphs cfg is a directed graph unique node start from which all nodes in cfg are reachable. Floyds algorithm implemented in pgrouting can also answer reachability question. Lengauer and tarjan 74 presented an algorithm for computing dominators in om. It runs in linear time, matching the time bound for alternative methods including kosarajus algorithm and the pathbased strong component algorithm. And subsequent optimization phases can then determine whether a cfg node dominates another node in constant time by using their respective depth. Tarjans algorithm to find strongly connected components. Lengauer and tarjan 38 gave two nearlineartime algorithms for computing d that run. Lengauer and tarjan 17 proposed two versions of a fast algorithm for finding. Gsoc 2019 graph c boost graph algorithms for pgrouting. This paper describes an algorithm for finding dominators in an arbitrary directed graph.
The lengauertarjan algorithm is a fast algorithm for general flowgraphs. We wish to construct the dominator tree of an arbitrary flowgraph g. Comparing our work with lengauer tarjan provides meaningful informa. Tree height general case an on algorithm, n is the number of nodes in the tree require node. The algorithm is quite complex and i have to admit i havent taken the time to fully understand it, im just using it. The lengauertarjan algorithm is better understood, however, and has a clear implementation. Harvey, and ken kennedy of rice university describe an algorithm that essentially solves the above data flow equations but uses well. The first one is, as an intermediate step, finding semidominator which is relatively easier to evaluate than immediate dominator, and the second one is the path compression. The algorithm uses depthfirst search and an efficient method of computing functions defined on paths in trees. Tarjans strongly connected components algorithm graph.
1621 52 736 1482 454 790 467 1496 308 1533 774 1630 1461 1142 688 613 1631 658 562 916 1224 833 931 536 360 374 292 320 89 1339 581 756 3 186 292 328 1407